Shelter Island House

Average Kiwi Rating


Kiwi Rating Explained

Food & Beverage
Spa & Fitness
Attention to Detail
Generosity & Value
Wow / Hip Factor
Architecture & Design
Fit to Promise

Nightly Rates from:

USD 170
Nightly Rates From

This price represents the lowest nightly rate found at this property over the next 60 days. Actual rate may vary based on seasonality and availability.


Call us to find out about your preferred dates

Send Availability Request

Send us a request about your preferred dates

Send Availability Request

A hotel that dates back to the 1800’s, Shelter Island House is a potential ‘home away from home” for those to whom Crescent Beach on Shelter Island sounds like an attractive neighbor.

A wonderful scene made up of white fences, delightful deck furniture, and brilliant gazebos greets guests at Shelter Island House. Dark woods and fashionable furniture create intimate interiors… where white linens, cream walls, and restful furnishings convey an aura of beautiful beach life.

Just eight rooms welcome guests into their pristine spaces. Gaze out at a tranquil garden view from a window seat, tub, or big bed, then close your eyes and breathe in the calming air and enchanting tranquility of this property.

When the beach beckons, make your way to the lounge bar or outdoor bar in the garden… before trying out your indoor or outdoor dining options. Dine fireside in winter and al fresco in summer; the phrase “out of season” does not apply to Shelter Island House.

New touches like an in-house bakery, bicycles, and Bocci Ball have further enhanced its beauty. For a modern beach vacation with traditional touches and timeless style, give Shelter Island House a try.
We currently are unable to display any general room type information for Shelter Island House. To get room availability please send us an availability request or contact us by phone at 1.877.999.0680

Checking availability for:


We’re sorry, there was an error processing your request. To resolve this, please submit your dates again using the top search bar.
  • Lounge/Bar
  • Meeting / Private Room
  • Restaurant(s)
  • Swimming Pool - Outdoor
  • Flat Screen TV
  • Front Desk
  • High Speed Internet (Complimentary)
  • High Speed Internet (Wireless)
  • In-room safe
  • iPod dock in rooms
  • Non-Smoking Rooms
  • Outdoor Dining & Lounging Area
  • Parking
  • Turndown Service
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Gastronomy
  • Mountain Biking
  • Relaxing
  • Tennis

We go to great lengths to ensure the information and advice we provide is authentic and accurate. The guest reviews appearing on our site are written by people who booked through Kiwi Collection and stayed at the hotel. In other words, the reviews are written by verified hotel aficionados like you!


Situated near the famous Crescent Beach, Shelter Island House can be reached by ferry from Greenport, or seaplane from the East River in forty minutes.


Contact Hotel

Our hotel reservation specialists are available to assist with your hotel reservations, itinerary changes, or questions.

PHONE: +1.877.999.0680
EMAIL: Reservations Team

Monday to Friday 6am – 12am
Saturday and Sunday 7am - 3pm
Hours of operation are in Pacific Standard Time.
  • Shelter Island House
  • 11 Stearns Point Road
  • New York
  • Shelter Island 11965
  • United States